Thursday, April 7, 2011
Saturday, April 2, 2011
THE BEST OF THE WEB: This is from Slate and I dare you to read this and not get bat-shit crazy angry.
Cruel but Not Unusual
Clarence Thomas writes one of the meanest Supreme Court decisions ever.
By Dahlia LithwickPosted Friday, April 1, 2011, at 7:43 PM ETIn 1963, in Brady v. Maryland, the Supreme Court held that prosecutors must turn over to the defense any evidence that would tend to prove a defendant's innocence. Failure to do so is a violation of the defendant's constitutional rights. Yet the four prosecutors in Thompson's case managed to keep secret the fact that they had hidden exculpatory evidence for 20 years. Were it not for Thompson's investigators, he would have been executed for a murder he did not commit.
Both of Thompson's convictions were overturned. When he was retried on the murder charges, a jury acquitted him after 35 minutes. He sued the former Louisiana district attorney for Orleans Parish, Harry Connick Sr. (yes, his dad) for failing to train his prosecutors about their legal obligation to turn over exculpatory evidence to the defense. A jury awarded Thompson $14 million for this civil rights violation, one for every year he spent wrongfully incarcerated. The district court judge added another $1 million in attorneys' fees. A panel of the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the verdict. An equally divided 5th Circuit, sitting en banc, affirmed again.
Advertisement

But this week, writing on behalf of the five conservatives on the Supreme Court and in his first majority opinion of the term,Justice Clarence Thomas tossed out the verdict, finding that the district attorney can't be responsible for the single act of a lone prosecutor. The Thomas opinion is an extraordinary piece of workmanship, matched only by Justice Antonin Scalia's concurring opinion, in which he takes a few extra whacks at Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg's dissent. (Ginsburg was so bothered by the majority decision that she read her dissent from the bench for the first time this term.) Both Thomas and Scalia have produced what can only be described as a master class in human apathy. Their disregard for the facts of Thompson's thrashed life and near-death emerges as a moral flat line. Scalia opens his concurrence with a swipe at Ginsburg's "lengthy excavation of the trial record" and states that "the question presented for our review is whether a municipality is liable for a single Brady violation by one of its prosecutors." But only by willfully ignoring that entire trial record can he and Thomas reduce the entire constitutional question to a single misdeed by a single bad actor.
Both parties to this case have long agreed that an injustice had been done. Connick himself conceded that there had been a Brady violation, yet Scalia finds none. Everyone else concedes that egregious mistakes were made. Scalia struggles to rehabilitate them all.
One of the reasons the truth came to light after 20 years is that Gerry Deegan, a junior assistant D.A. on the Thompson case, confessed as he lay dying of cancer that he had withheld the crime lab test results and removed a blood sample from the evidence room. The prosecutor to whom Deegan confessed said nothing about this for five years. While Scalia pins the wrongdoing on a single "miscreant prosecutor," Ginsburg correctly notes that "no fewer than five prosecutors" were involved in railroading Thompson. She adds that they "did so despite multiple opportunities, spanning nearly two decades, to set the record straight." While Thomas states the question as having to do with a "singleBrady violation," Ginsburg is quick to point out that there was far more than just a misplaced blood sample at issue: Thompson was turned in by someone seeking a reward, but prosecutors failed to turn over tapes of that conversation. The eyewitness identification of the killer didn't match Thompson, but was never shared with defense counsel. The blood evidence was enough to prove a Brady violation, but it was the tip of the iceberg.
In the 10 years preceding Thompson's trial, Thomas acknowledges, "Louisiana courts had overturned four convictions because of Brady violations by prosecutors in Connick's office." Yet somehow this doesn't add up to a pattern of Brady violations in the office, because the evidence in those other cases wasn't blood or crime lab evidence. Huh? He then inexplicably asserts that young prosecutors needn't be trained on Brady violations because they learned everything in law school.
Scalia and Thomas are at pains to say that Connick was not aware of or responsible for his subordinates' unconstitutional conduct, except—as Ginsburg points out—that Connick acknowledged that he misunderstood Brady,acknowledged that his prosecutors "were coming fresh out of law school," acknowledged he didn't know whether they had Brady training, and acknowledged that he himself had 'stopped reading law books … and looking at opinions' when he was first elected District Attorney in 1974." And Connick also conceded that holding his underlings to the highest Brady standards would "make [his] job more difficult." As Bennett Gershman and Joel Cohen point out, the jury had "considerable evidence that both Connick and prosecutors in his office were ignorant of the constitutional rules regarding disclosure of exculpatory evidence; they were ignorant of the rules regarding disclosure of scientific evidence; there was no training, or continuing education, and no procedures to monitor compliance with evidentiary requirements; prosecutors did not review police files; and shockingly, Connick himself had been indicted by federal prosecutors for suppressing a lab report of the kind hidden from Thompson."
It's not just that a jury, a judge, and the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals found that Connick knew his staff was undertrained and he failed to fix it. It's that it's almost impossible, on reviewing all of the evidence, to conclude anything else. Nobody is suggesting that the legal issue here is simple or that there aren'tmeaningful consequences to creating liability for district attorneys who fail to train their subordinates in Brady compliance. But those aren't the opinions that Thomas and Scalia produced. Their effort instead was to sift and resift the facts until the injury done to Thompson can be pinned on a single bad actor, acting in bad faith. It's a long, sad, uphill trek.
Beyond that, there is no suggestion in either opinion that this is a hard question or a close call or even a hint of regret at their conclusion. There is only certainty that the jury, the appeals court, and above all Ginsburg got it completely wrong in believing that someone should be held responsible for the outrages suffered by John Thompson. If there is empathy for anyone in evidence here, it's for the overworked and overzealous district attorneys.
It's left to Ginsburg to acknowledge that the costs of immunizing Connick from any wrongdoing is as high as the cost of opening him to it: "The prosecutorial concealment Thompson encountered … is bound to be repeated unless municipal agencies bear responsibility—made tangible by §1983 liability—for adequately conveying what Brady requires and for monitoring staff compliance." As Scott Lemieux points out, by all-but-immunizing Connick for the conduct of his subordinates, the court has created a perfect Catch-22, since the courts already give prosecutors absolute immunity for their actions as prosecutors (though they may still be liable for their conduct as administrators or investigators). By immunizing their bosses as well, the court has guaranteed that nobody can be held responsible for even the most shocking civil rights violations.
I don't think that the failure at the court is one of empathy. I don't ask that Thomas or Scalia shed a tear for an innocent man who almost went to his death because of deceptive prosecutors. And, frankly, Ginsburg's dissent—while powerful—is no less Vulcan in tone than their opinions. But this case is of a piece with prior decisions in which Thomas and Scalia have staked out positions that revel in the hyper-technical and deliberately callous. It was, after all, Scalia who wrote in 2009 that "this court has never held that the Constitution forbids the execution of a convicted defendant who had a full and fair trial but is later able to convince a habeas court that he is 'actually' innocent." It was Thomas who wrote that a prisoner who was slammed to a concrete floor and punched and kicked by a guard after asking for a grievance form had no constitutional claim.
The law awards no extra points for being pitiless and scornful. There is rarely a reason to be pitiless and scornful, certainly in a case of an innocent man who was nearly executed. It leads one to wonder whether Thomas and Scalia sometimes are just because they can be.
Thursday, March 10, 2011
Wednesday, March 9, 2011
Nourishment For Your Brain
"A government which robs Peter to pay Paul, can always count on the support of Paul." -- George Bernard Shaw
Huckleberry Finn: In Trouble Again
This has been in the news of late so I’m sure some of you are aware of this controversy surrounding Mark Twain’s Adventures of Huckleberry Finn. Southbooks recently announced that it would publish an updated version of Twain’s classic. What, you might ask, does that exactly mean? Huck and Jim adrift on the Mississippi River; finding their way with a GPS device; the widow Douglas vacuuming her rugs with a Dyson; or maybe we might find that Pap has joined a twelve step program? God knows he needs one.
Well, we aren’t that lucky. The updating involves replacing the 219 times “nigger” appears in the text with the word “slave.” For the added enjoyment of the modern reader the editors are also replacing the word “injun” in the text with the word “pineapple.” I jest; the word injun will become Indian. Don’t ask me. The only reason I can think of is that the modern reader would consider the word ‘Injun” to be an epithet when actually, in the novel, it’s really simply just the way people in Huck’s socioeconomic class pronounced the word Indian. If they wanted to insult an injun they would have used words like, red devil or heathen savage.
Adventures of Huckleberry Finn is one of the most banned book in the world. After it was published in 1885 it only took a few weeks for the banning to start and it doesn’t look to be slowing down anytime soon. At the bottom of all this you’ll probably find that the loudest critics haven’t read it.
Fundamentally, there are three reasons people want the book banned, Twain’s use of the word nigger, the way Jim is portrayed in the book, and it fails to depict the way the south really was at that time in history.
First it needs to be said that Adventures of Huckleberry Finn is the first truly American novel to have appeared on the literary scene up to that point. It’s the first book dealing with American themes; using American characters who were not portrayed as warmed over Brits; and talking in the way Americans talked. I know this might come as a shock to some of you modern readers but Americans use all the words that Twain puts in the mouths of his characters…all of them…including the word nigger. At the time it was a demeaning, derogatory word aimed at slaves in particular but black people in general. It hadn’t yet taken on the unrivaled power that the word has today. Of course it matters who is using it and for what reason. Isn’t that the way with all words? That word is one of the most important words in the text; remove it and you eviscerated the power of the novel and you make Huck’s epiphany at the end of the book mean almost nothing. The word is used in a variety of ways depending on who uses it. That word in particular gives you an insight into the character who uses it. There is a big difference between Pap’s use of the word and Huck’s. Pap spits it out with hatred and Huck almost just uses it as an identifier. In Huck’s world that seems to be what you call black people. Huck hasn’t been as yet indoctrinated into the evils of that word, but he will learn to hate all that it represents by the end of the book and choose not to be part of it and, instead, affirm Jim as his friend.
Second, some people feel that Jim is portrayed as a simpleton, as an Uncle Tom type of character. This is absurd on the face of it. You don’t even have to read the text closely to see that Jim is the only, let me repeat, the only character who is pure of heart. He treats everyone he meets with kindness and respect. He is gentle and loving. His innocence is the counterpoint to everyone else in the book. Jim is the only good man through and through in the book. His is dignified in his dealings with everyone. He is the example of how a human being ought to act.
Thirdly, people criticize the book because it doesn’t illustrate the South accurately. This, of course, really depends on who is doing the illustrating. Twain was a Southerner and for a short time found himself a member of a Confederate Militia at the beginning of the war. He left after a few days and hightailed it out west to avoid all contact with the war. As a Southerner his voice seems to have taken over and overshadowed Hucks. I have some startling news for you. Twain wasn’t trying to depict the South. He was trying to depict a world that has Huck at its epicenter using the South as the background.
There can be no modern version of Huck Finn. That, my friends, is something of an oxymoron. The version Twain wrote stands alone as a colossus of American Literature. The only one who has the right to change anything in the text is the writer. You have a choice. You can read the book as it was meant to be read and have yourself an experience that goes to the heart of who we are as a people. If you think you might be offended at the use of the words “nigger” or “injun” or even “pineapple” then you can choose to not read it and that’s the way it should be.
Previously published in 365ink.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


